Ever since the great Swing Era trumpeter Bunny Berigan drank himself to death at age 33, the enduring mystery has been "Why?"

Paul playing the trumpet

CAST

Headshot of Renee Beaumont, actor

Renee Beaumont is ...

Donna Berigan

... Donna Berigan

Susan Brickell is ...

Mayme Berigan

... Mayme Berigan

Paul Keegan is ...

    ... Bunny Berigan

Headshot of Noah Kleinberg, actor

Noah Kleinberg is...

Bix Beiderbecke sitting with his cornet

... Bix Benderback (inspired by Bix Beiderbecke)

Headshot of David Nash, actor

 David Nash is ...

Tommy Dorsey with trombone

 ... Tommy Dorsey

                                          

Lee Wiley, singer

... Lee Wilson (inspired by Lee Wiley)

SYNOPSIS

Set in a speakeasy and featuring a live band, I Can’t Get Started follows the trumpeter Bunny Berigan as he clashes with his wife Donna, falls in love with the troubled singer Lee Wilson, and implores his best friend Tommy Dorsey to help him start an interracial big band. With lyricism, humor and high drama, the play explores the spiritual cost of broken dreams in 1930s America. “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom” meets “Death of a Salesman” in this riveting tale of passion with a swing beat.

ABOUT THE PLAY

Bunny Berigan playing trumpet with a jazz band.

     Bunny Berigan had it made. A virtuoso trumpet player, handsome and successful, he became a national sensation with his 1937 hit, "I Can’t Get Started."

 

     Five years later, he was dead.


     The official cause of death, at age 33, was cirrhosis of the liver – in this case, too much whiskey. 


     Ever since, the jazz world has been haunted by the mystery of how this brilliant artist, in the prime of life, could have self-destructed so quickly and completely. 

     That question has always intrigued Paul Keegan, a writer, actor, and trumpet player who decided to invent an answer for the stage. The result is I Can’t Get Started, a work of historical fiction more than two decades in the making. 

  

     Conceived as a memory play, the story begins with an older Bunny going back in time to his early days in New York, where his romantic notions about music, love, and racial harmony collide with reality. As a white musician in a world dominated by Black innovators, he struggles with questions of authenticity and the demands of a ruthless music business. Along the way, Bunny's volatile love life, obsession with music as a mystical experience, and thirst for booze begin to turn his idyllic visions into a nightmare.


Below: Bunny Berigan (left) during his affair with the singer Lee Wiley (center).

Bunny Berigan with Lee Wiley (center)

      During his research, Keegan was struck by what an enigma the musician was, even to his biographers. “There’s endless detail about the exterior of Bunny’s world – bands, recording dates, tours – but almost nothing about his inner life," he says. "That provided an irresistible blank canvas to work with, and it's been fascinating to venture beyond his public facade to imagine Bunny's ambitions and disappointments, his joys and fears – then follow those leads to the play's dénouement."


     Though not a musical, I Can’t Get Started is saturated with music, from the swinging sounds of a live jazz band to a storyline that dramatizes the power of music to shape our understanding of the world. Productions at nightclubs around New York City are designed to re-create the atmosphere of the Onyx Club, a vibrant speakeasy on 52nd Street, giving audiences a thrillingly immersive experience.

Renee Beaumont, Noah Kleinberg, and Paul Keegan rehearsing at HB Studio..

     Most of the top-notch actors in this production – including Keegan’s co-director, Noah Kleinberg – study at the venerable HB Studio in Manhattan, where the play was developed under the tutelage of the late playwrights Donna DeMatteo and William Packard and the distinguished acting teacher Michael Beckett. 


     "We've been so fortunate to work with Michael and the talented actors in HB's professional-level program," says Kleinberg. "It's been exciting to watch the play grow and come alive."

    During the project’s long gestation, Keegan kept his eye on his ultimate goal. “I want to bring people to that magical place where only live theater and music can take us,” he says.  "That's the place where Bunny experiences his greatest happiness and deepest sorrows. We hope the audience goes with him, giving Bunny's music — and his spirit — a second life.”


Photo: Rehearsal at HB Studio with Renee Beaumont as Donna Berigan, co-director Kleinberg, and Keegan as Bunny Berigan.

PRODUCTIONS

February 3-4, 2023

Spoke The Hub Winter Follies '23

Spoke's Gowanus Arts Annex, 298 Butler Street, Brooklyn, New York

Event Details

February 3-4, 2023

Spoke The Hub Winter Follies '23

Opening monologue by Bunny Berigan performed by Paul Keegan. Winter Follies is a performing artist competition streamed online.

Spoke's Gowanus Arts Annex, 298 Butler Street, Brooklyn, New York

March 25, 2023

Spoke The Hub '23 Salon

Spoke's Wheelhouse Theater, 748 Union Street, Brooklyn, New York

Event Details

March 25, 2023

Spoke The Hub '23 Salon

Opening monologue by Bunny Berigan performed by Paul Keegan as part of artist's showcase.

Spoke's Wheelhouse Theater, 748 Union Street, Brooklyn, New York

December 14, 2024

Spoke The Hub Holiday Benefit Showcase

Spoke's Wheelhouse Theater, 748 Union Street, Brooklyn, New York

Event Details

December 14, 2024

Spoke The Hub Holiday Benefit Showcase

Act II, Scene 1 featuring Bix Benderback (Noah Kleinberg) and Bunny Berigan (Paul Keegan).

Spoke's Wheelhouse Theater, 748 Union Street, Brooklyn, New York

UPCOMING SHOWS

Watch this section for news about upcoming performances!

Watch this section for news about upcoming performances!

Contact Us

Send Message

Attach Files
Attachments (0)

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Better yet, see us in person!

For inquiries about upcoming productions, send us a message.


We will get back to you soon!

Blue Soul Jazz Productions

53 E. 34th Street, Suite 309, New York 10016

Email us at paul@icantgetstarted.com

Subscribe

Sign up for our newsletter!

Copyright © 2026 I Can't Get Started - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept